Three years on, kin of Mangalore crash victims still look for fair redress

[email protected] (Sajila Saseendran, KT, Photos by Ahmed Anwar)
May 22, 2013
alg_india_crash_flames

Mangalore, May 22: There is no memorial remaining in the names of the 158 victims of the crash of Air India Express flight from Dubai in Mangalore on May 22, 2010.

However, memories of their near and dear ones lost in one of the worst crashes in India continue to haunt hundreds of residents in the UAE and India as prayers and tears mark the third anniversary today.

Only eight passengers had survived when flight IX 812 from Dubai overshot the tabletop runway at Mangalore's Bajpe Airport and caught fire after it plunged into a valley that morning.

The scars remain in their memories. But many of the victims' relatives have not given up the fight to make sure that they receive the compensation they deserve.

Their legal battle to ensure that all crash victims' next of kin receive a minimum compensation of 100,000 SDRs (Special Drawing Rights, roughly Dh520,000) as per the Montreal Convention is still continuing in the Supreme Court of India. They hope that the verdict will be in their favour and will be a precedent in compensating any future crash victim's family, albeit praying for no such tragedy to strike anyone else.

Air India's legal counsel Hoshang D Nanavati, while speaking to Khaleej Times from Mumbai, said all victims' dependents were compensated either on full and final basis or as per the judgment of the Kerala High Court. Air India has reportedly paid more than Rs1.15 billion (about Dh78 million) for the settlement.

He also hoped that the case in the Supreme Court will be finalised in the next hearing posted in November. The verdict will now depend on the interpretation of the Carriage by Air Act in India with respect to the Montreal Convention to be given by the Union Government of India at the Supreme Court.

According to Mohammed Beary, president of the Mangalore Air Crash Victims' Families Association, some families have received compensation in multi-millions, the maximum being Rs80 million for the family of a businessman who perished in the crash.

However, that doesn't mean that everybody has got what they deserve, he said from Mangalore.

“Our demand is that there should be a minimum payment of Rs7.5 million in respect of the death of each passenger as per the Montreal Convention. In the case of non-working women and children, the average compensation given was just Rs3.5 million and Rs2.5 million, respectively.”

Relatives who feel that the compensation given to them is not enough have gone to the court as per their will. Beary said 19 compensation claims are still pending in Mangalore and some others in Kerala.

Dubai residents Santhosh Rai and Abdul Rahman, who lost their wives and children, are among those who moved the court.

“We are sure that we will win the cases, especially in the Supreme Court. And it will be a benchmark or precedent for any such compensation claims in future, though we pray that such a fate should not happen to anyone else,” said Rahman.

“It is not for the money for me that I am fighting the case. I have seen the pain and struggle of many families. Many families could not go for cases as they cannot afford the court fee. If we don't fight for them, tomorrow some others will also face the same plight.”

Some of the victims' spouses have started a new life after remarrying. But for Rahman, the family members of other victims have become his own extended family.

“I am in touch with many of them. My life has become lifeless and I consider them as my family members now. “You know, I can't sit at home with peace of mind. Neither can I go anywhere else. Wherever I went, I used to take my wife and son along… I cannot spend a day without missing them,” he said, breaking down in tears.

The screams of many mothers and children like them still haunt Puttur Ismail Abdulla who survived the crash with spinal injuries. A store manager in Deira, the 38-year-old man believes that God gave him a second life to bless his only daughter who was an infant at that time.

He came back to work in the same company two years ago and had travelled home twice in the same flight to the same airport. “The landing time is the worst thing I'm afraid of. I cannot explain what I feel at that time,” said Abdulla.

Air_crash__1

Air_crash__2

Air_crash__3

Air_crash__4

Air_crash__5

Air_crash__1

Air_crash__7

Air_crash__8

Comments

Add new comment

  • Coastaldigest.com reserves the right to delete or block any comments.
  • Coastaldigset.com is not responsible for its readers’ comments.
  • Comments that are abusive, incendiary or irrelevant are strictly prohibited.
  • Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name to avoid reject.
News Network
December 15,2025

Mangaluru, Dec 15: Educational institutions in Mangaluru that rely on the popular Mangala Stadium for their annual sports events are bracing for an inconvenience as the city's key sporting venue is set to close its gates for a significant upgrade. The stadium is expected to be unavailable for approximately two months starting from January 15, 2026.

The closure is necessitated by a proposed overhaul of the stadium's facilities, with a special focus on upgrading the synthetic track. Pradeep Dsouza, Assistant Director of the District of Youth Empowerment and Sports (DYES), Dakshina Kannada, confirmed the development.

"Experts have visited the stadium, conducted a thorough inspection, and have given the go-ahead for a complete makeover," Dsouza stated. "Funds have been allocated for the project, and we are currently awaiting the final green signal from state officials to commence the work. We anticipate that the work will likely begin in the second week of January. Consequently, we have stopped renting out the stadium to colleges and other organizations in preparation for the upgrade."

The timing presents a logistical challenge for colleges, as many schools have already concluded their sports meets.

"Colleges will now be organizing their events and will need to find alternative locations to host their sports meets," Dsouza added. He suggested a few potential venues, including the Dakshina Kannada police ground, University College grounds, Panambur grounds, Swaraj Maidan in Moodbidri, and the Mangalore University sports grounds in Konaje.

However, many institutions note that finding a comparable venue will be difficult. While the DK police ground and University College grounds are closer to the city center, they do not possess the extensive facilities and infrastructure offered by Mangala Stadium.

Dr. P Dayananda Pai - P Satisha Govt First Grade College, Carstreet, is one such institution dependent on the stadium. Principal Jayakar Bhandary expressed hope for a swift completion of the work. "We expect the work to be completed at the earliest. If not, we will be forced to look for other venues to host the sports day for our students," Bhandary said, highlighting the pressing need for the city's main sporting facility.

Comments

Add new comment

  • Coastaldigest.com reserves the right to delete or block any comments.
  • Coastaldigset.com is not responsible for its readers’ comments.
  • Comments that are abusive, incendiary or irrelevant are strictly prohibited.
  • Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name to avoid reject.
News Network
December 19,2025

Mangaluru: In a decisive move to tackle the city’s deteriorating sanitation infrastructure, the Mangaluru City Corporation (MCC) has announced a massive ₹1,200 crore action plan to overhaul its underground drainage (UGD) network.

The initiative, spearheaded by Deputy Commissioner and MCC Administrator Darshan HV, aims to bridge "missing links" in the current system that have left residents grappling with overflowing sewage and environmental hazards.

The Breaking Point

The announcement follows a high-intensity phone-in session on Thursday, where the DC was flooded with grievances from frustrated citizens. Residents, including Savithri from Yekkur, described a harrowing reality: raw sewage from apartments leaking into stormwater drains, creating a "permanent stink" and turning residential zones into mosquito breeding grounds.

"We are facing immense difficulties due to the stench and the health risks. Local officials have remained silent until now," one resident reported during the session.

The Strategy: A Six-Year Vision

DC Darshan HV confirmed that the proposed plan is not a temporary patch but a comprehensive six-year roadmap designed to accommodate Mangaluru’s projected population growth. Key highlights of the plan include:

•    Infrastructure Expansion: Laying additional pipelines to connect older neighborhoods to the main grid.

•    STP Crackdown: Stricter enforcement of Sewage Treatment Plant (STP) regulations. While new apartments are required to have functional STPs, many older buildings lack them entirely, and several newer units are reportedly non-functional.

•    Budgetary Push: The plan has already been discussed with the district in-charge minister and the Secretary of the Urban Development Department. It is slated for formal presentation in the upcoming state budget.

Comments

Add new comment

  • Coastaldigest.com reserves the right to delete or block any comments.
  • Coastaldigset.com is not responsible for its readers’ comments.
  • Comments that are abusive, incendiary or irrelevant are strictly prohibited.
  • Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name to avoid reject.
News Network
December 5,2025

Mangaluru: In a significant step to curb online hate and intimidation, Mangaluru City Police have registered a suo motu case against multiple Instagram accounts accused of circulating alleged provocative and threatening content.

While monitoring social media activity on Tuesday, Kankanady Town PSI Anitha Nikkam identified the Instagram handle ‘team_targetttt_900’ for posting a hate message alongside images of lethal weapons. Another account, ‘team_nagara_900’, allegedly shared a threatening post targeting activist Bharath Kumdelu, tagging additional pages such as KARAVALI-OFFICIAL.

Several other accounts — including ‘immu_bhai.fan’, ‘target_boy_900’, ‘kings_of_manglore’, ‘team_target_boys.900’, ‘arshad_mangalore’, ‘target_ka19_ullal’, ‘team_target__’, ‘troll_tigersz_900’, ‘tr_group_900’, and ‘team_target_900’ — are also under scrutiny for spreading similar inflammatory material, police said.

Authorities have urged citizens, especially young social media users, to report suspicious pages and avoid engaging with groups that glorify violence or threaten individuals. Online hate can quickly escalate into real-world harm, and police stress that sharing or promoting such content can attract legal consequences.

Comments

Add new comment

  • Coastaldigest.com reserves the right to delete or block any comments.
  • Coastaldigset.com is not responsible for its readers’ comments.
  • Comments that are abusive, incendiary or irrelevant are strictly prohibited.
  • Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name to avoid reject.